A manuscript critique is a big-picture evaluation of your story or nonfiction book and is a recommended first step. We'll take a close look at all the important narrative elements.

For fiction & memoir

We'll analyze your hook to make sure it grabs readers, and we'll carefully examine your plot, pacing, and overall length. We'll also dive into your characters—how believable are they? Do they grow and change throughout the story? We'll also pay close attention to your writing style, looking at things like point of view, dialogue, and how you use descriptions.

For nonfiction

We'll scrutinize your thesis and arguments, making sure they're strong and well-supported. We'll also evaluate how you organize your ideas and the depth of your research. We'll make sure your work flows smoothly and keeps readers engaged throughout.

You'll receive a detailed editorial letter with 8–10 pages of feedback and an opportunity to chat with your editor to discuss a plan for revisions.

An evaluation is vital if you are seeking an expert opinion on your work, suggestions on what to revise, and guidance on the next steps.